Edmonton's Dual Signings Send Mixed Messages About Championship Window
Well, well, well. The Edmonton Oilers just pulled off the most Oilers move possible on Monday afternoon, and I'm not sure whether to applaud or scratch my head. In the span of two hours, they managed to both secure their franchise player and potentially handcuff themselves with a defenseman's contract that might age like milk in the Alberta sun.
Let's start with the good news that has Oil Country breathing a collective sigh of relief: Connor McDavid isn't going anywhere... for now. The captain inked a two-year, $25 million extension that keeps him at his current $12.5 million AAV through 2027-28. That's right, folks – the best player on the planet just gave the Oilers exactly two more kicks at the can after this season ends.
The McDavid Deal: Bridge to Where?
Here's what's fascinating about McDavid's short-term commitment: it's essentially a "show me" contract from a guy who's already shown us everything. Three Hart Trophies, five Art Ross Trophies, and he's dragged this franchise kicking and screaming to respectability. Yet he's only willing to commit for two more years? That should tell you everything about where his head's at.
The timing couldn't be more perfect – or calculated. His buddy Leon Draisaitl already locked himself up long-term, so McDavid knows he'll have an elite running mate. But two years? That's Connor saying, "I'll give you until I'm 30 to prove this organization can win the big one." After that, all bets are off, and every team with cap space will be sliding into his DMs faster than you can say "Toronto Maple Leafs."
At $12.5 million, McDavid remains criminally underpaid. This guy could command $15-16 million on the open market without breaking a sweat. The fact he's maintaining his current AAV is either a generous hometown discount or a strategic move to keep the team competitive. Probably both.
The Walman Gamble: Seven Years of What Exactly?
Now, about that Jake Walman contract – seven years at $7 million per? Someone in the Oilers front office must've been day-drinking Oil Kings beer when they hammered out those terms.
Don't get me wrong, Walman was solid after coming over from San Jose at the deadline. The 29-year-old put up 40 points last season between the Sharks and Oilers, and he showed some playoff moxie with 10 points in 22 games. But here's the kicker – this guy has played 267 career NHL games. Total. Over six seasons. And now he's getting term and money like he's Cale Makar's cousin?
Let's do some quick math here. Walman will be 36 when this deal expires. Thirty-six! For a defenseman who's had exactly one season where he played more than 65 games. The Oilers are betting $49 million that a guy who bounced between St. Louis, Detroit, and San Jose before finding his game is suddenly going to be their defensive cornerstone for the better part of a decade.
The Risk-Reward Calculation
Here's where it gets interesting – and potentially disastrous. The Oilers are clearly in win-now mode with McDavid's clock ticking louder than ever. Walman's deal suggests they believe he's the missing piece on the back end, the guy who can quarterback that power play when Evan Bouchard inevitably prices himself out of Edmonton.
But seven years? That's longer than most marriages in Hollywood. That's betting this late-blooming defenseman won't turn into a boat anchor contract by year four. Remember when the Oilers thought Milan Lucic and James Neal were good long-term investments? Pepperidge Farm remembers.
The message is clear: Edmonton has exactly two years to deliver Connor McDavid his Stanley Cup. After that, who knows? Maybe he re-ups for another short deal, maybe he decides he wants to chase cups elsewhere, or maybe – just maybe – the Oilers actually break their 35-year championship drought and everyone lives happily ever after.
The Walman signing suggests they're not messing around. They're pushing chips to the middle of the table, consequences be damned. Will that $7 million AAV look terrible in 2029? Probably. Do the Oilers care right now? Absolutely not.
The Bottom Line
Monday's signings perfectly encapsulate the Oilers' predicament: desperately trying to maximize a generational talent's prime while making moves that could haunt them down the road. McDavid's two-year deal is both a vote of confidence and an ultimatum. Walman's seven-year pact is either shrewd asset management or future salary cap suicide.
In typical Oilers fashion, there's no middle ground here. They're either about to embark on a two-year run that ends with Connor McDavid hoisting Lord Stanley's Cup on Jasper Avenue, or they're setting themselves up for the most spectacular implosion in franchise history – and that's saying something.
Either way, the next two years in Edmonton just got a whole lot more interesting. McDavid's given them a deadline. Walman's given them another weapon. Now Ken Holland and company need to figure out how to turn potential into parades.
The clock's ticking, Edmonton. No pressure.
Post a Comment